|
|
|

IssueAlert Emerging Technologies ~
June, 2003
What Surprises You About the
Utility Industry?
Customer Care
Service Vendors Speak
By Jon T. Brock, Chief Operating Officer, UtiliPoint
The 27th annual CIS Conference continued in Nashville on Monday
with a full day of vendor and utility sessions on customer care
in the utility industry. After listening to the presentations and
speaking with attendees at the conference, a key theme emerged:
In almost every utility today in North America there is a "return
to the basics" strategy. With the advent of re-regulation in
North America, utilities are increasingly focused on efforts to
satisfy their customer base. To accomplish this, utilities are concentrating
on four major areas:
- Reliability of Service: Utilities are attempting to improve
their level of service by adding new technologies, addressing
aging facilities, expanding tree-trimming efforts, and expanding
capacity.
- Customer Contact Centers: Utilities are endeavoring to make
sure that all customer queries are handled in a timely and knowledgeable
manner.
- New Products & Services: Utilities are offering new products
and services in an attempt to Increase customer satisfaction.
- Stable Prices: As fuel costs fluctuate, utilities are seeking
to maintain a stable price.
In yesterday's
IssueAlert, Christopher Perdue provided an analysis
of what the utilities are saying at the CIS conference in relation
to recent survey data on customer care in North American utilities.
Today, I would like to focus on what the various vendors are saying
in relation to current market conditions in the utility industry.
UtiliPoint International recently interviewed 26 customer care
executives for the CIS Conference on several factors, ranging from
what utilities are requesting most to what the future holds for
customer care technology vendors. To obtain a complimentary copy
of UtiliPoint's Customer Care interviews in their entirety, visit:
www.utilipoint.com/rci/specialreports.asp.
Outsourcers of Customer Care Services Speak
When asked, "What has been most surprising to you during
the past year in this marketplace? " providers of outsourced
customer care responded in a variety of ways. Michael Juliano, Senior
Vice President of Technology & Professional Services for Alliance
Data Systems replied, "The thing that most surprises us about
this marketplace is how a few of the more notorious industry issues
have caused some significant collateral damage to some very good
utilities. The opportunity for Alliance is to turn this unfortunate
situation into a win for all parties, as these good companies are
now being forced to look at how to improve productivity, gain operational
efficiency and produce better bottom line results. Over the past
four years, we've demonstrated our ability to deliver in these areas."
Alliance Data Systems is a single source provider of outsourced
billing and customer care solutions to the regulated, transitioning
and deregulated energy industry, serving millions of utility customers.
Alliance manages outsourced billing and customer care business processes
for utilities.
"I am continually surprised at how many utilities I meet that
permit large tolerances in their collections activities," said
Michael Gardner, President of Cayenta, Inc. "So much attention
is being put into developing systems that give a good visual profile
of a customer, provide excellent customer relationship management,
and empower utilities to automatically trigger aggressive collection
streams, yet so few seem to do it. We have been working closely
with our customers to understand their intentions when it comes
to revenue recovery. In our experience, many of them are being equipped
with the right tools to make changes to their collections and customer
management practices, but often they are unsure as to how to enact
these practices. Information is only powerful when it is acted upon,
and it surprises me that more organizations have not stepped up
and recognized that creating and implementing the tools is only
one part of their job-they have to show utilities how to use these
tools, and measure the effectiveness of them." Cayenta provides
customer care software directly to multi-commodity utilities in
the municipal, cooperative, and investor-owned sectors but also
provides it in an outsource model as well.
"The most surprising aspect of the current marketplace is
the willingness of some major players in the energy industry to
reconsider their outsourcing strategies," said Dwight Willett,
President and Chief Executive Officer of Accenture/CustomerWorks,
Inc. "This has taken the form of both reassessing what their
own core competencies truly are, and of reevaluating current outsourcing
relationships not just for price, but overall value. This is an
encouraging sign, as it demonstrates a true commitment to not only
shareholder value, but to the strategic focus that will allow good
customer care decisions to contribute to corporate growth for years
to come."
Accenture/CustomerWorks is a business process outsourcer performing
services for several Canadian utilities, including BC Gas, BC Hydro
and recently announced Enmax.
"The past year has been a difficult financial time in the
IT industry, utilities and the economy in general," said Paul
Kluba, Chief Operating Officer for Daffron & Associates. "We
are seeing many utilities put buying decisions on hold. As a rule,
utilities are a fairly conservative group, but we have been able
to add new customers and continue to add new functionality for our
existing customers. I am also surprised that legislation toward
deregulation is still on hold for many areas of the country. This
has been somewhat consistent with the economy and the uncertainty
with the war, but I originally felt that electric deregulation across
the U.S. would come at a faster pace. Also surprising in regards
to deregulated markets is the legislation and political pressures
for enactment of changes after the market was open. Some areas have
taken a step backward by putting caps on pricing." Daffron
& Associates provides customer care solutions to116 electric
cooperatives, 37 municipalities and 7 IOUs, with an e-bill option
being provided via an outsource model.
"As I sit back and reflect upon the past few years or so,
it is simply amazing where we were, and where we are," said
David Steele, Vice President of Business Development for First Contact,
Inc. "I can remember all of us chasing UtiliCorp under Richard
Green's leadership in the early days of deregulation. They appeared
to have the model for the future, which was the 1 million plus customer
utility that also provided an array of consumer products and applied
technology to all of their business processes. Then we followed
Enron. And it turned out, none of those models proved viable in
the long-term. Now what we are hearing is 'back to core, cost containment,
and focus on the customer.' Ironically, this is the basic form of
monopolistic structure. It is back to why monopolies developed in
the first place - to Provide one investment in public infrastructure,
reducing the costs to all while providing the basic services of
safe, reliable and low cost energy distribution. This model was
furthermore supported by an overriding philosophy of a public obligation
to serve. To insure the appropriate level of service and pricing
occurred, oversight was established in the form of public utility
commissions who act as the watchdogs on behalf of consumers. Now,
when you think of that, it certainly looks like we are right back
to the basics doesn't it?" First Contact is a customer relationship/customer
contact outsourcing firm that is part of IntelliRisk Management
Corporation headquartered in Columbus, Ohio.
"What is most surprising tome has been the quick comeback
of retail marketing in certain areas," said Carl Kloecker,
Executive Vice President of NirvanaSoft. "Energy companies
who have extensive experience in wholesale markets are doing well
serving large customers in deregulated markets, especially in the
Northeast and Mid-Atlantic States. Retail marketing strategies are
appearing on a regular basis from companies who survived the shake
out, have the credit rating and want to be in the business. A good
example is Dominion Virginia Power's proposal to Reduce the extra
wires charge recently." Nirvanasoft provides software to enable
complex billing and provides it as an outsourced option via the
Energy Services Group.
"With the economy pressuring businesses to Reduce costs,
we are somewhat surprised that many utilities are still reluctant
to make changes—i.e., outsourcing—in how they use their capital
and resources," said Jamie Biddle, CEO of Orcom. "Outsourcing
typically reduces the total cost of ownership for a utility billing
and CIS solution by up to30 percent and preserves their capital
budget. Outsourcing also avoids disruptions to a utility's business.
In comparing our outsourced solution to a licensed software purchase,
implementation risk must be factored in. According to an October
2001 Wall Street Journal article, roughly 38 percent of utility
CIS implementations fail. Even successful implementations are distracting
to an organization, consuming the attention of a utility's most
knowledgeable and experienced staff. The longer the implementation
takes, the more likely the staff will lose focus or the project
will fail. Outsourced solutions tend to implement very quickly,
typically in less than half the time required to implement a licensed
software based system, because the IT infrastructure is already
in place and the base software is also installed and tested. Thus,
the major focus in outsourcing is placed on software configuration,
training and testing. This not only speeds things up by eliminating
many of the up-front decision making tasks that licensed software
projects entail, but also results in a better outcome." Orcom
provides outsourced customer care to utilities in North America.
"With our organization the focus currently is on deregulation
and legislation tied to deregulation, said Dana Holmes, Director
of Marketing & Sales for Viterra Energy Services. "We feel
that one of the important next steps in opening markets is the unbundling
of the meter device, and both Texas and Virginia recently passed
on moving the metering issue forward." Viterra Energy Services
provides outsourced customer care including sub-metering expertise
to the utility and energy service provider industry.
In concluding, the vendors at the CIS Conference this year report
an increased level of interest in new customer care systems ranging
from CIS/CRM to call center applications. Interest from the utilities
also varies between licensed products and outsourced services. What
surprises the vendors about the energy industry varies also, but
is generally related to a specific service that they offer. Expect
to see more alignment between the utilities' needs and the vendors
who provide the software, technology, and services to meet those
needs as the utility industry redefines itself over the next few
years.
An archive list of previous IssueAlert articles
is available at:
www.utilipoint.com
UtiliPoint's Emerging Technologies IssueAlert articles
are compiled based on the independent analysis of UtiliPoint
consultants, researchers, and analysts. The opinions expressed
in UtiliPoint's Emerging Technologies IssueAlert articles
are not intended to predict financial performance of companies
discussed, or to be the basis for investment decisions of
any kind. UtiliPoint's sole purpose in publishing its Emerging
Technologies IssueAlert articles is to offer an independent
perspective regarding the key events occurring in the energy
industry, based on its long-standing reputation as an expert
on energy issues.
©2003, UtiliPoint International, Inc. All rights
reserved. This article is protected by United States copyright
and other intellectual property laws and may not be reproduced,
rewritten, distributed, redisseminated, transmitted, displayed,
published or broadcast, directly or indirectly, in any medium
without the prior written permission of UtiliPoint, Inc.
|
|